News

Trump to press Modi for talks with Pakistan on Kashmir

Will also raise CAA, NRC with Indian PM: Delhi to ‘reciprocate’ by offering no trade deal

February 22, 2020 12:51 PM


Twitter Share Facebook Share WhatsApp Share

During his touch-and-go visit to India, US President Donald Trump will encourage a reduction in tensions and bilateral dialogue between India and Pakistan.

Trump is also expected to raise US concerns around the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and National Register of Citizens (NRC) with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, when he visits India next week, says a White House official in a briefing to reporters on Friday. Trump will also encourage a reduction in tensions and bilateral dialogue between India and Pakistan on Kashmir while in India, he said.

The comments are significant at a time when there is a growing concern in Washington over India’s adherence to democratic processes and traditions, namely, Parliament’s passage of the CAA and the establishment of the NRC in Assam.

In response to a question on whether Trump will raise the CAA and NRC with Modi, the official said the administration is "concerned" about these issues and that Trump will talk about these issues with Prime Minister Modi. Particularly, Trump is expected to raise the "religious freedom issue" which is "extremely important" to the current US administration as well as discuss shared traditions of democracy and religious freedom "both in public remarks and certainly in private," the official said.

"Prime Minister Modi in his first speech after winning the election last year talked about how he would prioritize being inclusive of Indian religious minorities. And certainly, the world looks to India to maintain religious liberty and equal treatment for all under the rule of law," the official said.

Responding to a question, the official said Kashmir will be raised and Trump would very much encourage a "reduction in tensions" between India and Pakistan and encourage them to engage in bilateral dialogue to resolve differences.

"We continue to believe a core foundation of any successful dialogue between the two is based on continued momentum in Pakistan's efforts to crack down on extremists on its territory. We continue to look for that. I think the President will urge both countries to seek to maintain peace and stability along the Line of Control and refrain from actions or statements that could increase tensions in the region," the official said.

On whether Trump would ask India to send troops to Afghanistan, where the US announced it has finalised an agreement with the Taliban to reduce violence, the official said if the Afghanistan issue were to come up during Trump’s India visit, the US would look to India to support the peace process. 

No trade deal for Trump

Trump will open the world's biggest cricket stadium and watch the sunset at the famed Taj Mahal during a lightning visit to India starting Monday, but behind the spectacular optics, he is expected to face a protectionist counter-punch on trade.

Trump's blossoming bromance with Prime Minister Modi that will be on show again belies prickly relations, particularly over commerce, with both men ramping up protectionist measures.

Experts say this has hurt US efforts to make India a strategic counterweight to China, while Trump's mediation offer in the long-running Kashmir dispute with Pakistan has annoyed New Delhi.

"We're not treated very well by India, but I happen to like Prime Minister Modi a lot," Trump, 73, said before his maiden official visit to the nation of 1.3 billion with First Lady Melania, daughter Ivanka and son-in-law Jared Kushner.

The US president arrives in the western state of Gujarat where Modi's record while chief minister as a reformer and flag-bearer of Hindu nationalism catapulted him to the national stage in 2014.

Trump told a rally on Thursday that "six to 10 million people" would be along the route of his motorcade, but this appears to be a misunderstanding. Organisers said there will be tens of thousands.

A 700-metre wall has been built, allegedly to hide a slum, while construction workers have been rushing to complete the Sardar Patel Stadium.

It will be rammed with around 100,000 people for an event dubbed "Namaste Trump", payback for a "Howdy, Modi" rally in Houston last year in front of some of America's vast Indian diaspora.

- Pizza cheese -

The Trumps will then fly to the Taj Mahal, the white marble "jewel of Muslim art" according to UNESCO, but afterwards, it will be down to business in New Delhi on Tuesday.

Reports suggest Trump and Modi may agree to a modest trade pact covering items including imports of Harley-Davidson motorcycles and US dairy products such as pizza cheese, as well as a number of defence and other deals.

But this will fall short of the comprehensive agreement the world's largest economy and the planet's biggest democracy have been seeking for years.

Tanvi Madan from the Brookings Institution said the lack of progress on trade was the "big missing deliverable", forcing both sides to focus more on the "great optics" of the visit.

Trade relations have worsened as Trump's "America First" strategy to reduce the US trade deficit bumps up against Modi's "Make in India" drive as Asia's third-largest economy flags.

Although small fry compared to his trade war with China, Trump in 2018 levelled tariffs on steel and aluminium from India - and elsewhere - and in June stripped India of its preferential trade status.

Delhi responded with hiked duties on a raft of US agricultural goods such as almonds, and restricted imports of certain medical devices. More tariffs were announced in the recent budget.

"We're doing a very big trade deal with India," Trump said before the visit but conceded it may not be done before US elections in November. 

This was echoed on Thursday by India's foreign ministry which said it did not want to "rush into a deal".

And there are other sources of mutual irritation.

Trump and Modi may ink a $2.4-billion deal for US helicopters, but overall when it comes to arms, Russia remains India's biggest supplier.

A US decision is outstanding on whether to slap sanctions on New Delhi for its planned purchase of Russia's S-400 missile defence system.

Energy-hungry India was also irked by US pressure to stop buying Iranian oil, while Delhi's plans to force foreign firms to store Indian consumers' personal data inside the country has also worried US businesses.

India has bristled at criticism in Washington about its recent security and communications lockdown in Kashmir, as well as of a contentious new citizenship law seen as anti-Muslim.

But Harsh Pant from the Observer Research Foundation in Delhi said Trump coming to India sends an important signal to other countries that relations remain "close" despite these differences.

"To be fair to India, they have managed Trump much better than others including key US allies like Japan, Australia and other Western European countries," Pant told AFP.



Most Read

  1. Mexican claims victory by paying $28 for $28,000 Cartier earrings Mexican claims victory by paying $28 for $28,000 Cartier earrings
  2. Two Railway Police personnel killed in Mardan Two Railway Police personnel killed in Mardan
  3. Gunmen storm Lucky Cement factory, kill security guard Gunmen storm Lucky Cement factory, kill security guard
  4. When Pakistani pilot shot down Israeli fighter plane When Pakistani pilot shot down Israeli fighter plane
  5. Relationships are tough; Mrunal Thakkur plans to freeze her eggs Relationships are tough; Mrunal Thakkur plans to freeze her eggs
  6. Arbaaz Khan hands ‘winning’ response to ex-wife Malaika Arora for labelling him Indecisive Arbaaz Khan hands ‘winning’ response to ex-wife Malaika Arora for labelling him Indecisive

Opinion

  1. PML-N smashed PTI in by-polls
    PML-N smashed PTI in by-polls

    By News Desk

  2. Riding the Digital Wave: How Technology is Rewriting the Script of Economic Prosperity
    Riding the Digital Wave: How Technology is Rewriting the Script of Economic Prosperity

    By News Desk

  3. Tax on solar energy: Govt's misplaced priorities favour powerful stakeholders over people welfare  
    Tax on solar energy: Govt's misplaced priorities favour powerful stakeholders over people welfare  

    By Manzoor Qadir

  4. Legacy of Indian military subjugation in Kashmir
    Legacy of Indian military subjugation in Kashmir

    By Dr Ghulam Nabi Fai

  5. Islamabad becoming the hub of international diplomacy
    Islamabad becoming the hub of international diplomacy

    By Salim Bokhari

  6. Insights into the Pakistan Stock Exchange's Recent Record High Triumph
    Insights into the Pakistan Stock Exchange's Recent Record High Triumph

    By Zulfiqar Ali Mir