Image Alt Text

News

Madrid court rejects partial lockdown as harmful to basic rights

October 8, 2020 06:02 PM


Madrid's top regional court on Thursday rejected a partial lockdown imposed at the weekend on the capital and nine nearby towns to slow the rapid spread of coronavirus infections.

A court statement said it "had denied the ratification (of the measures) on grounds they impacted on the rights and fundamental freedoms" of the 4.5 million residents affected by the closure, which went into force late Friday night.

Under the restrictions, residents are not allowed to leave the city limits except for work, school or medical reasons as the region battles a soaring infection rate of well over 700 cases per 100,000 people, compared with just 257 per 100,000 in the rest of Spain -- in itself the highest rate in the European Union.

Without the measures being ratified by the court, police have no legal grounds for issuing fines for non-compliance -- which they have not yet done pending the court's decision.

In their ruling, the regional judges said the health ministry, which imposed the restrictions, did not have the right to do so because responsibility for public health matters lies with Spain's 17 autonomous regions.

Accordingly, the measures outlined in the health ministry's order "constitute an infringement by the public authorities on the citizens' fundamental rights without legal authorisation," the judges found.

The measures were agreed last week at talks between the health ministry and its counterparts in most of the regions.

Although Madrid's regional leaders agreed to implement the restrictions, they expressed strong opposition and filed their own challenge at Spain's National Court, which remains pending.

When the pandemic erupted in March, the Spanish government declared a state of emergency which gave it the power to impose and enforce a lockdown across the entire country.

But since that ended on June 21, it is the regions that have had responsibility for public health and managing the pandemic.



Most Read

  1. Hackers steal data of over 2m Pakistanis from restaurants Hackers steal data of over 2m Pakistanis from restaurants
  2. Naseem Shah's fitness in doubt for World Cup after medical report Naseem Shah's fitness in doubt for World Cup after medical report
  3. Shagufta Ejaz under fire for sharing reproductive health condition Shagufta Ejaz under fire for sharing reproductive health condition
  4. Punjab issues Rs32,000 minimum salary notification Punjab issues Rs32,000 minimum salary notification
  5. TikToker gang-raped by three at Dadu party TikToker gang-raped by three at Dadu party
  6. Unfair elimination of Natasha Ali in ‘Tamasha’ shows saddens fans Unfair elimination of Natasha Ali in ‘Tamasha’ shows saddens fans

Opinion

  1. Orange Line Metro Train: Bridging Nations and Palates – Mr. Yunlin's Unforgettable Moments in Lahore
    Orange Line Metro Train: Bridging Nations and Palates – Mr. Yunlin's Unforgettable Moments in Lahore

    By Ali Ramay

  2. India’s invasion of Kashmir is violation of UN Charter
    India’s invasion of Kashmir is violation of UN Charter

    By Dr Ghulam Nabi Fai

  3. World Suicide Prevention Day: Creating Hope Through Action
    World Suicide Prevention Day: Creating Hope Through Action

    By Dr Asif Channer

  4. Gender equality: A pre-requisite for a balanced society
    Gender equality: A pre-requisite for a balanced society

    By Mehak Sabir

  5. Time to move on and build a better Pakistan
    Time to move on and build a better Pakistan

    By Murtaza Rafiq Bhutto